We have 2 servers! Yay! So... how do we configure things so that our users hit each server randomly? Why, a load balancer of course! Setting up a load balancer has nothing to do with Ansible, but let's take a quick tour anyways!
I've already loaded up my EC2 Control Panel. Click "Load Balancers" on the left to create an "Elastic Load Balancer". To keep things simple, I'll create a "Classic" load balancer, but you should use an "Application Loader" balancer. That type is better, but a little more complex and beyond what I want to cover in this tutorial.
Give it a name - "MooTube-LoadBalancer" and make it respond only to HTTP traffic. You can also configure your load balancer to allow HTTPS traffic... which is amazing, because AWS can handle the SSL certificate automatically. Ultimately, the entire SSL process is resolved by the load balancer, and all requests - including secure requests - will be forwarded to our servers on port 80, as HTTP. This means we get HTTPS with basically no setup.
For the health check, keep
index.html - I'll talk about why in a minute.
I'm going to lower the interval and healthy threshold, but you can keep this: I'm
only doing this so that the load balancer will see our new servers faster.
Finally, select the 2 running instances: "MooTube recording" is our original server - I renamed it manually - and "MooTube instance" is the new server we just launched.
Ok, create it! Look at the "Instances" tab: both servers are listed as "OutOfService".
That's normal: it's testing to make sure the servers work! How does it test? By
making a request to the IP address of each server,
Go copy the IP address to one of the servers and try this! Woh! It's the "Welcome to Nginx" page from the default virtual host. This is why our health check will pass.
A better setup might be to make MooTube our default virtual host, so that you see the site even when you go to the IP address. That would be really nice because, right now, even though the health check will pass, it doesn't actually mean that MooTube is working on this server. It would be nicer to health check the actual app.
Go back to the "Instances" tab. Yes! Both instances are now "InService".
So how can we test this? Every load balancer has a public DNS name. Copy that... then
try it in a browser! Oh... it's that same "Welcome to Nginx" page! Our load balancer
is sending our traffic to one of the servers... but since the host name is not
mootube.example.com, we see the default virtual host.
In a real situation, we would configure our DNS to point to this load balancer. The Route 53 service in AWS let's you do this really easily. The tricky thing is that, as you can see, it does not list an IP address for the load balancer! What!? That's because the IP address might change at any time. In other words, you can rely on the DNS name, but not the IP address.
Since this is a fake site... we can't setup the DNS properly. So, to test this, we're going to cheat! Go to your terminal and ping the DNS name:
The ping will fail, but yes! There is the IP address to the load balancer. Like
I said, do not rely on this in real life. But for temporary testing, it's fine!
/etc/hosts file, and point this IP address to
# /etc/hosts # ... #22.214.171.124 mootube.example.com #126.96.36.199 mootube.example.com 188.8.131.52 mootube.example.com
Ok, let's try it! Open a new Incognito window and go to
Yes! It works! With no videos, this must be the new server! Refresh a few more times.
I love it: you can see the load balancer is randomly sending us to one of the two
Now that we're behind a load balancer... we have a new, minor, but important problem.
Suppose that, in our app, we want to get the user's IP address. So,
Guess what? That will now be the wrong IP address! Instead of being the IP of
the user, it will always be the IP of the load balancer!
In fact, a bunch of things will be wrong. For example,
return false, even if the user is accessing our site over
https. The port and
even the host might be wrong!
This is a classic problem when you're behind a proxy, like a load balancer. When
the load balancer sends the request back to our server, it changes a few things:
REMOTE_ADDR header is changed to be the load balancer's IP address. And
if the original request was an
https connection on port 443, the new request will
appear insecure on port 80. That's because the load balancer handled the SSL stuff.
To help us, the load balancer sets the original information on a few headers:
X-Forwarded-For holds the original IP address and
X-Forwarded-Proto will be
There are some standards, but the exact headers used can vary from proxy to proxy.
This means that our app needs to be smart enough to read these headers, instead of the normal ones. Symfony doesn't do this automatically, because it could be a security risk. You need to configure it explicitly.
Google for "Symfony reverse proxy". Ok! In our front controller - so
in Symfony 3, we need to call
setTrustedProxies() and pass it all possible IP
addresses of our load balancer. Then, when a request comes into the app from
a trusted IP address, Symfony knows it's safe to use the
and will use them automatically.
But... AWS is special... because we do not know the IP address of the load balancer!
It's always changing! In that case, copy the second code block. Open
and - right after we create the request - paste it:
|... lines 1 - 22|
|$request = Request::createFromGlobals();|
|// Real client IP is under HTTP_X_FORWARDED_FOR for requests through AWS ELB,|
|// i.e. REMOTE_ADDR holds AWS ELB IP instead|
|// trust *all* requests|
|// if you're using ELB, otherwise see https://symfony.com/doc/current/request/load_balancer_reverse_proxy.html|
|... lines 33 - 37|
Thanks to this code, we're going to trust every request that enters our app. Wait, what!? Doesn't that defeat the security mechanism? Yes! I mean... maybe! When you trust all proxies like this, you must configure your servers to only accept port 80 traffic from your load balancer. In other words, you need to configure your EC2 instances so that you cannot access them directly from the public web. The details of doing that are out of the scope of this tutorial. But once you've done this, then it is safe to trust all requests, because your load balancer is the only thing who can access your server.
Next! Let's get crazy, setup continuous integration, and auto-deploy our code after the tests pass! Nice!